In the battle of Human-powered Design vs AI-driven Design, the human-powered design relies on the intuition, empathy, and imagination of designers to craft visually appealing and meaningful experiences. On the other corner, AI-driven design utilizes algorithms and data-driven approaches to automate the design process, creating designs faster and more efficiently.
Designing for the future: the age-old debate of human touch vs technology takes a new twist. However, with the advent of AI and machine learning, the question on everyone’s mind is whether machines will take over the creative process or will the human touch continue to reign supreme.
Explaining Modern Web Designing Stages
Today, both human-created Design and AI design processes have to follow the below six stages of web designing:
a) Forming (The creator analyzes client requirements to assess the web design context)
b) Defining (The creator drafts the complete set of requirements to create a development roadmap)
c) Ideating (The creator generates creative ideas to meet the design requirements)
d) Socializing (The creator represents the design ideas to the clients for confirmation)
e) Implementing (The creator implements high-quality designs for deploying)
To understand the impact of AI today, we would have to break down the web designing stages for further examination.
Comparing Web Designing Stages: Human-powered design vs AI-driven design
Let’s compare the theoretical and AI capabilities to perform activities in each web designing stage.
Forming
In this first stage, the human designers have to perform the following activities:
a) Inquire about unique design context to plan the right design solution.
b) Explore different perspectives to form different design strategies.
c) Combine the stakeholders’ vision with the design concept.
Today’s web designers use various AI tools to perform the above tasks. However, AI systems like ChatGPT are bound to offer only generic advice toward functional differentiation. Hence, these fail to consider human emotions that feed the initial design idea.
Defining
Considering the future of design technology, adapting AI systems for this process is crucial for designers to draft an initial project plan. It collects detailed information based on business requirements and end-user expectations.
In this process, AI systems like ChatGPT offer faster solutions than human brains. AI systems utilize digitally collected data to suggest suitable design plans and strategies. It provides faster data processing speed and performs reasonably well than humans.
Ideating
Designers brainstorm their minds to create unique design ideas in this phase. Many designers follow their past experiences to define newer ideas relevant to the client’s expectations. Today’s impact of AI on design industry is that designers use AI systems to generate design ideas based on user inputs. Naturally, the usage of UI and UX designing tools is increasing among developers.
Socializing
Once the design ideas get ready, the designers consider client recommendations and end-user feedback to enhance the design results. Often, designers focus on their aesthetic intuitions to choose the best idea. Today, designers use various tools to create a strong point of view that combines human creativity and AI in design. AI helps sort out ideas faster using attention data and previous data design models.
Implementing
Finally, the designer completes developing all design components. AI systems can boost this step. Designs can use AI tools to fine-tune their implementation by performing continuous reviews. AI enables designers to generate UI or UX development codes with complete syntaxes using the existing codebase.
Pros and Cons of AI-driven Design
Being aware of the capabilities of AI-driven design tools, graphic designers can benefit from the following pros:
Pros: Content Personalization
AI can develop and update creative content, which is challenging for content creators. AI uses data metrics of customer behavior to create relevant and market-centric design concepts. It helps target specific audiences worldwide.
Pros: Developing Variations
The AI-assisted design offers different variations derived from a single idea. AI cultivates alternative data-driven design solutions to create multiple design variations. So the designer can create as many unique instances as he wants!
Pros: Speed and Accuracy
Undoubtedly, AI systems provide more accurate design solutions than humans at the fastest speed. It can collect, analyze, and process vast volumes of data within minutes. Plus, there are no chances of error occurrence.
Cons: No Understanding of Empathy
The role of AI in design process is to improve accuracy, fasten development, and bring variations. AI doesn’t have the understanding of raw feelings or empathy like humans. Naturally, it fails to connect with the idea behind the design!
Cons: Lacks Originality
The primary focus of human creativity is on the ability of designers to create original design contexts. AI cannot deliver originality like humans, as AI will always use the pre-stored data sets to create variations.
Cons: AI is not for non-technical people
Human-centered design and AI design use tools and technologies, but AI is highly technical. Web designers with little technical knowledge cannot use AI systems as per their true potential.
A Glimpse To The Future
So where are we standing in the face of Machine Learning and AI? Today web designers are using various software to reduce the required designing efforts. In each step of the web designing process, human creators depend on multiple tools and technologies. With technological advancement, it’s hard to convey a clear verdict for Human-powered design vs AI-driven design. AI cannot match human creators’ dedication, emotion, and originality. Still, it will be interesting to discover how the world will adopt AI for designing. Consult professional UI UX design experts to choose what’s best for your business!
Design that tells a story, crafted by hand vs Design beyond imagination, powered by AI – Choose wisely!
About Us: Algoworks is a B2B IT firm providing end-to-end product development services. Operating chiefly from its California office, Algoworks is reputed for its partnership with Fortune 500 companies such as Amazon, Dell, Salesforce, and Microsoft. Algoworks is an expert in UI/UX Designs with experience catering to enterprises belonging to all domains. This includes: Brand Strategy, Product Design, UX Research, UI & Animation and Design Testing. For more information, contact us here.
Nauman Ahmad
